Wednesday, May 28, 2025
LBNN
  • Business
  • Markets
  • Politics
  • Crypto
  • Finance
  • Energy
  • Technology
  • Taxes
  • Creator Economy
  • Wealth Management
  • Documentaries
No Result
View All Result
LBNN

Spy Bill “missing the bus” on preventing political abuse – ISS

Simon Osuji by Simon Osuji
December 22, 2023
in Military & Defense
0
Spy Bill “missing the bus” on preventing political abuse – ISS
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Minister in The Presidency, Khumbudzo Ntshavheni.

Despite recently narrowing its scope and abandoning vetting of non-governmental organisations, South Africa’s controversial “Spy Bill” still does not address the core challenge of civilian oversight to prevent political abuse and the continuation of State Capture of its intelligence services, experts say.

On the eve of the public participation phase of its legislative journey in 2024, an unabated litany of criticism and warnings by security and intelligence experts, supported by a broad swathe of civil society, grows against the General Intelligence Laws Amendment Bill of 2023 (GILAB) in its latest iteration.

“In the wake of State Capture and severe abuse by political parties, the outcome of this legislation was supposed to make the statement ‘never again’. This is the golden opportunity to rectify the wrongs of the past, but we seem to be missing the bus,” according to intelligence expert Willie Els.

GILAB was introduced nine months late to Parliament by Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni in early 2023. She is now accused of attempting to rush the bill before the 2024 General Election.

Ntshavheni claims GILAB is not an attempt to create a surveillance state in South Africa but has gone on to sharply accuse the business sector of seeking to “destabilise the State”, a move some experts believe is in reality a spur to the present factionalised intelligence services to harass and monitor outspoken anti-government business leaders as elections approach.

In its most recent iteration, churches and NGOs are excluded from monitoring following vociferous civil society objections, but security companies remain targets for security clearances and surveillance. However, criticism of vague and vapid terminology presently in the draft legislation, even on basic definitions such as “intelligence” is also growing.

The core issue of institutionalised civilian oversight – or rather the complete lack of it – has still not been addressed in the latest legislative version along with crucial checks and balances on the powers of politicians such as Ntshavheni to meddle politically in intelligence operations.

Even South Africa’s Inspector General of Intelligence (IGI) Imtiaz Fazel has warned that GILAB should seek to strengthen oversight of South Africa’s intelligence structures, especially the IGI through pro-active law making and definitions.

It seems obvious that the SA Government plans to limit public participation in the legislative development of GILAB to maintain the ability to continue the abuse of intelligence services for personal and political gain, said Els, a senior manager at the Pretoria-based Institute for Security Studies (ISS).

“Minister Ntshavheni is setting up herself and other future ministers and politicians as judge and jury within GILAB because there is no civilian oversight and most tellingly, no appeal mechanism in the legislation. This creates impunity for politicians and their official minions to abuse intelligence structures,” said Els.

Although the term State Capture is a relatively recent one, in truth all South Africa’s  intelligence structures were politically captured as far back as 1994 when police, military and civilian intelligence structures were officially  “integrated” – taken over by a flood of ANC cadre deployment with a smattering of other liberation forces.

This situation has continued for almost three decades to the present day – with dire and disastrous results for policing and military structures – and is exactly what GILAB is supposed to counter but apparently is de facto intending to keep entrenched, said Els.

“Even being charitable, Minister Ntshavheni and her State Security Agency (SSA) officials seem completely out of their depth especially given the past abuse of intelligence services by both apartheid and democratic governments in the past and up to the present day,” he said.

GILAB is a bill that aims to overhaul the legislative framework for national security and intelligence services in South Africa.

It proposes to dis-establish the SSA and reconfigure the intelligence services into four entities: separate foreign and domestic intelligence services, a National Communications Centre (NCC) and the establishment of a SA National Academy of Intelligence (SANAI).

The proposed legislation also intends restricting former intelligence officials from using their secret knowledge for various purposes.

GILAB also introduces new definitions of key terms such as “national security”, “potential opportunity”, “hostile interests”, “critical infrastructure” and “cyber-security”. These definitions are supposed to provide clarity and guidance for intelligence activities, but some critics argue they are too broad and vague and could be used to justify excessive surveillance and interference.

Recently, the term vetting was dropped from the legislation to be replaced by the broad concept of “security competence”. The legislation now also refers to “opportunities” to improve national security, which opponents argue gives space for abuse by politicians.

GILAB has been met with mixed reactions from various stakeholders from its outset, including civil society, religious groups, opposition parties, human rights organisations and former intelligence officials. Some welcomed the bill as a necessary step to modernise and strengthen the intelligence sector, while others expressed concerns about its potential impact on democracy, privacy, accountability and oversight.



Source link

Related posts

Thyssenkrupp, Saab, to Collab on MEKO A-200 Platform

Thyssenkrupp, Saab, to Collab on MEKO A-200 Platform

May 28, 2025
SiMa.ai’s Vision for AI in Disconnected Environments

SiMa.ai’s Vision for AI in Disconnected Environments

May 28, 2025
Previous Post

[ENCORE] DOJ Visit and Independence Day. Conversation with author Juliet Mitchell

Next Post

Dengue spike fuels concerns of public health threat in previously untouched countries: World Health Organization (WHO)

Next Post
Dengue spike fuels concerns of public health threat in previously untouched countries: World Health Organization (WHO)

Dengue spike fuels concerns of public health threat in previously untouched countries: World Health Organization (WHO)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED NEWS

Musk is helping remove ‘constraints’ to speed up Air Force One delivery: Boeing CEO

Musk is helping remove ‘constraints’ to speed up Air Force One delivery: Boeing CEO

3 months ago
The 39 Best Shows on Disney+ Right Now

The 39 Best Shows on Disney+ Right Now

2 years ago
Scientists warned a decade ago American lives were shortening. Then it got worse : Shots

Scientists warned a decade ago American lives were shortening. Then it got worse : Shots

2 years ago
Deepfake, AI or real? It’s getting harder for police to protect children from sexual exploitation online

Deepfake, AI or real? It’s getting harder for police to protect children from sexual exploitation online

11 months ago

POPULAR NEWS

  • Ghana to build three oil refineries, five petrochemical plants in energy sector overhaul

    Ghana to build three oil refineries, five petrochemical plants in energy sector overhaul

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • When Will SHIB Reach $1? Here’s What ChatGPT Says

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Matthew Slater, son of Jackson State great, happy to see HBCUs back at the forefront

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Dolly Varden Focuses on Adding Ounces the Remainder of 2023

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • US Dollar Might Fall To 96-97 Range in March 2024

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 LBNN - All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Markets
  • Crypto
  • Economics
    • Manufacturing
    • Real Estate
    • Infrastructure
  • Finance
  • Energy
  • Creator Economy
  • Wealth Management
  • Taxes
  • Telecoms
  • Military & Defense
  • Careers
  • Technology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Investigative journalism
  • Art & Culture
  • Documentaries
  • Quizzes
    • Enneagram quiz
  • Newsletters
    • LBNN Newsletter
    • Divergent Capitalist

© 2023 LBNN - All rights reserved.